Best Natural Mascara: The Best and the Not-So-Great

I have been using (and loving) green beauty products for about three years now. So, I kind of have a lot to say about what I have tried, hence this best natural mascara review. One beauty product I could not live without is mascara. Without a doubt, it is my go-to makeup product and if I don't use anything else thats OK, but mascara is a must. So when I started to make the switch to natural mascaras, I was hesitant to give up my tried and true Lancome. In fact it was the last conventional product I made the switch over to when I first began this journey.

This post continues to get updated as I try new mascaras, this was last updated as of November 2021.

Before we chat about the best natural mascara brands I love, lets talk first about why I use natural products.

My top three reasons for going natural

  1. Hormone disruptors: Certain ingredients are known endocrine disruptors. Our endocrine system refers to a "collection of glands that produce hormones that help to regulate our metabolism, growth and development, tissue function, sexual function, reproduction, sleep, and mood, among other things." When we routinely use ingredients that are known to mess with our body in this way we may do any of the following: alter the production of hormones (either increasing or decreasing them), they may imitate other hormones, interfere with hormone signalling and even accumulate in our organs that produce hormones. When it comes to beauty and personal care products, watch for the following: phthalates (this is hidden in fragrance), formaldehyde (found in nail products, fake eyelash adhesives and hair dye), parabens, DEA/TEA/MEA (Ethanolamines), Diethylene glycol (or DEG) (found in fragrance and sometimes in glycerin and propylene glycol). One of the biggest things you can do is avoid items with fragrance. Fragrance is considered a trade secret in the beauty industry and they are not required to disclose what exactly is in them. There are more ingredients to watch for, you can find a good list here
  2. Lenient regulations: It saddens me that the regulations on cosmetics in both the U.S. and Canada is so lenient, especially when compared to the EU which has far more banned ingredients. The main issue I have with how ingredients and chemicals are approved is that they are not considered from a cumulative perspective. The buildup of these accumulated ingredients over time is what presents a bigger problem. The average woman uses 12 products daily totalling 168 unique ingredients. As I discussed above, fragrance or "parfum" is a term that allows a complete loophole for the cosmetic industry as they do not need to disclose what is included in this. And products such as toothpaste, antiperspirants, and anti aging lotions are not considered cosmetics which excludes them from following any cosmetic regulation altogether. 
  3. The Earth: What you choose to put on your body and throw away goes somewhere. Often times, when you use more natural products they also include better packaging that is friendlier on the environment. Beauty products like Kjaer Weis, use completely refillable makeup which I love. Just as organic food is better for the environment, so too is organic and truly clean makeup and beauty products. Other ingredients directly affect animals like fish, crustaceans, amphibians and more. All life on earth is dependent on the water cycle. Chemicals transferred to our water system can vaporize into the clouds and come back down as rain. Hence, every living being is affected. 

These mascaras are all ones that I have personally used over the years and have tested on myself. None of this is sponsored in any way. I do however use affiliate codes and as such receive a small commission from purchases made via my link.

best natural mascara Ilia

Best Natural Mascara That I Recommend:

100% Pure Mascara:

What I Like:

  • This was the first mascara I used when I first ditched the conventional ones I was using and I continued to use it for years.
  • I really like how it goes on and makes my lashes look full and long.

What I dislike:

  • It tends to get clumpy after about a month or so
  • it also ends up flaking and running which results in that annoying black line under your eye that you constantly need to keep wiping away.

Check out 100% Pure Mascara in the U.S. here!

Check out 100% Pure Mascara in Canada here!

Kjaer Weis:

What I Like:

  • It's refillable along with their whole range of products.
  • It's quite subtle: which is perfect for a soft everyday look.
  • Doesn't smudge

What I Dislike:

  • Not great if you want lots of volume or length

Check out Kjaer Weis Mascara in the U.S. here!

Check out Kjaer Weis Mascara in Canada here!

W3ll People Expressionist Mascara:

What I Like:

  • It provides decent lengthening

What I Dislike:

  • Smudged a lot over the day
  • Very hard to remove at night and I don't like rubbing my eye area to remove mascara.
  • I wouldn't repurchase

Check out W3ll People Mascara in the U.S. here!

Check out W3ll People Mascara in Canada here!

W3ll People Expressionist Volumizing Mascara:

What I Like:

  • Holds up very well throughout the day
  • Incredible volume
  • No flaking
  • Love the hourglass wand for reaching those hard-to-get lashes

What I dislike:

  • Can be a little hard to apply because of the brush size, it just takes a little practice and patience I find.

Check out W3ll People Mascara in the U.S. here!

Check out W3ll People Mascara in Canada here!

Here's a pic of me wearing the new mascara, the volume is AMAZING!

selfie with natural mascara

Sappho Paradigm Vegan Mascara:

What I Like:

  • Doesn't smudge
  • Lengthens very well
  • Easy to remove

What I Dislike:

  • The formula can be a bit thin
  • Doesn't give as much volume as I like

Check out Sappho New Paradigm Mascara in the U.S. here!

Check out Sappho New Paradigm Mascara in Canada here!

sappho mascara on table

Lily Lolo Best Vegan Mascara:

What I Like:

  • Doesn't flake or smudge

What I Dislike:

  • The texture was clumpy for me and did not apply well to my lashes.
  • I didn't like this one at all personally and wouldn't repurchase
lily lolo mascara

Hynt Nocturne Mascara:

What I Like:

  • Lengthening and volume was good
  • Good for a subtle everyday look

What I Dislike:

  • Smudged (quite a bit)
  • Could get a little clumpy

Overall, I wouldn't repurchase this one.

Fitglow Vegan Good Lash:

What I Like:

  • Provided decent length and volume
  • Easy to remove

What I Dislike:

  • It can smudge quite a bit
  • The price point is quite a bit higher than others

Check out Fitglow Mascara in the U.S. here!

Check out Fitglow Mascara in Canada here!

fitglow mascara

Ilia Limitless Lash Mascara

This is my NEW go-to mascara and it's the #1 best selling product at The Detox Market (for a reason). Seriously, the search for the best natural mascara is over, Ilia wins!

What I Like:

  • Provides the best volume and lengthening of any mascara I've tried
  • No smudging or flaking
  • Separates lashes very well
  • Love the brush with dual sides. The short side is for curl and volume and the longer side separates.
  • One coat is perfect, but you can build more volume with a second coat.

What I Dislike:

  • Nothing! Seriously, it's perfect.

Check out Ilia Limitless Lash Mascara in the U.S. here!

Check out Ilia Limitless Lash  Mascara in Canada here!

best natural mascara

Ilia Fullest Volumizing Mascara

What I Like:

  • It does provide pretty wicked volume.
  • Doesn't flake

What I Dislike: 

  • It can be very goopy from the bottle because too much excess product comes off.
  • It's hard to apply
  • The brush is a little too big for me.
  • Can be clumpy when applying
best natural mascara

RMS Beauty Straight Up Volumizing Peptide Mascara

What I Like: 

  • I love the formula with the peptides in it to support lash growth.
  • Goes on smoothly
  • Provides good volume

What I Dislike:

  • Can get clumpy when adding a second coat

Check out Ilia RMS Beuaty Straight Up Volumizing Peptide Mascara in the U.S. here!

Check out Ilia RMS Beuaty Straight Up Volumizing Peptide Mascara in Canada here!

best natural mascara

If you would like to purchase any products from The Detox Market's online Canadian store, please feel free to click here.

Or if you would like to shop the American site, feel free to shop here.

My code HOLISTICFOODIE10 will save you 10% at the Detox Market Canada website, it never expires!

Note: This code DOES NOT apply to sale section, product bundles such as the latest Detox Your Beauty Box, gift cards and all May Lindstrom, Kypris Beauty and Vintner’s Daughter products.This post contains affiliate links, which means I may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only share products and services I have personally used and love. Disclosure here.

What is the best natural mascara you've tried, let me know in the comments below!

best natural mascara

Comment

Did you love this? Let us know!

Name
Email
Message
Thanks for contributing to our community! Your comment will appear shortly.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
jaclyn
September 21, 2022
Hi Marnie! You could use about 3 to 4 tablespoons of nutritional yeast instead of parmesan.
Marnie
September 21, 2022
Hi, how much nutritional yeast would you suggest instead of cheese?
Jeanette
September 21, 2022
Absolutely LOVE this recipe - it's delicious (especially for those that like a hint of spice)!! My finance and I are obsessed and it's become part of our weeknight recipe rotation. It has a limited number of ingredients, it's quick to make/cook, but despite all of that - looks and tastes like much more time was spent! Thanks for the great recipe Jaclyn!
Matt
September 3, 2022
Do these burgers taste at all like beef? Thank you.
Grant
September 1, 2022
Just tried your recipe. Holly Hanna..... was that good! I know how to cook but you must try this one. I'm new to the this way of cooking but now I'm a believer. Keep them coming and I'll be trying them. Thanks ! G
Shafia
August 2, 2022
This was delicious!!! It takes some prep time but each portion is packed with flavour! Will definitely make again ❤️
Cristina
July 31, 2022
I made this yesterday and HOLY MOLY it hit the spot!!! It’s been so hot and muggy out here, so I was craving something light, cool, and filling. This recipe did not disappoint. The flavor of the peanut sauce was delicious. It had been a while since I prepared something with such color and flavor, which made eating it that much better. I will definitely make this again and try your other recipes too!! 😍🙏🏻❤️
Jaclyn
July 25, 2022
Hi Henrik! Thanks for letting me know you made them. Depending on the size of your food processor, it can be a lot to pulse all at once, so maybe working in batches is better. I'm glad you liked them and they firmed up for you :) Enjoy the rest!
henrik bechmann
July 25, 2022
Yep, they firmed up nicely. I'm freezing four, and looking forward to having the other four, dressed with sauerkraut, pickles, mustard, vegan mayo, onions, banana chiles, and maybe even ketchup. Yum!
henrik bechmann
July 25, 2022
Well I ended up baking them for 23 minutes (@400F). They're delicious! A bit soft, but I'm hoping they'll firm up when they cool. Texture is good too. Thanks for this!
henrik bechmann
July 24, 2022
Seems like a good and tasty recipe. But I had to add a generous half cup of water to get any kind of movement in the food processor. I substituted flax seeds for hemp (what I had). The mixture was a bit loose because of the water, but still formed nicely into patties. Baking for 15 min at 400F. Looking forward to them!
Jaclyn
July 23, 2022
Hi Roxanne! So for the meatballs photos with feta, I just used regular olive oil. But for the one photo with the red looking oil, that was olive oil mixed with fried green onions and Aleppo pepper. I have that recipe in full on my Instagram account - if you head over there, you'll see it - https://www.instagram.com/p/CbQXM2IlH4L/.
Roxanne
July 21, 2022
Hi! The topping on your whipped feta looked delicious. It appeared to be more than olive oil. Or maybe an infused olive oil? Do you mind sharing that recipe? I can’t wait to make this recipe. Appreciate the tip on room temp feta.
ANYA
July 19, 2022
Make these now! Once you buy your ingredients, this is the easiest recipe to execute...it's so hands off! I started the beef in the instant pot an hour before we wanted to eat and prepped the toppings while all of that was cooking. I used stewing beef and a home-made taco seasoning. I didn't have any beef broth so I used half of a bouillon cube - worked just fine! The enchilada sauce was store bought (Frontera brand) and it was delicious. Highly recommend the Monteray jack cheese - I used some Violife mozzarella that I happened to have at home but I can see how the sharp taste would add to the overall flavour.
Jaclyn
July 18, 2022
Hi Carolyn! I'm so glad you are loving my recipes, thank you so much for taking the time to let me know. I don't provide nutritional information as it doesn't align with my brand or how I personally choose to live my life, having had a disordered relationship to food in the past. I hope you understand :)
Carolyn
July 13, 2022
I love your recipes and have tried them! What would be GREAT is if you could include the nutritional value with calories. It would be beneficial to those of us trying to lose weight. Thank you, Carolyn
Julia
July 11, 2022
Just made this for my family today. I can’t have gluten or dairy but they can and this got a RESOUNDING stamp of approval! Love the simple ingredients and it tasted fabulous! Thanks for such nourishing recipes ❤️ 😊
Chris
July 3, 2022
Thanks for this! I came across this recipe very late in life, at a family meal. I liked it better than my mother's potato salad of my childhood, and better than my sister's which came from her in-laws. DH likes it very much. Win, win, win! Tip: if you don't want to steam up your summer kitchen nor fight the mosquitoes for the grill, pressure cook the potatoes!
MATILDE PAGAN
May 12, 2022
I am on a short vacation and came across this recipe, looking forward in making this. It looks really good. Can’t wait.
Whitney Mullenax
April 22, 2022
I have these cookies in the oven right now (2nd time making them in a few weeks). They are perfection and will be a great gift for some coworkers tomorrow. I made the recipe as is, great texture! I saved some for me too, don't worry ;)
Olivia Garcia
April 15, 2022
I love the ingredients in these recipes… Can’t wait to start them all!!
Anya
April 14, 2022
Don’t sleep on this wing recipe. It is soooo good! I can see this being a staple for game days, casual dinners or honestly…any day. Such a crowd pleaser as well. Oh and please don’t skip the dip. It’s unreal stuff! I was grabbing random things in my kitchen to eat it with once the wings were done.
Christa Campbell
March 28, 2022
The simplest recipe to make a delicious desert! I left out the cacao and just made vanilla coconut flavor and it was heavenly. I plan to add different flavors in the future; cacao with Orange or raspberry essence, vanilla salted, caramel flour de sel- the options are endless. Glad to find a keto friendly treat that can be made easily at home.
Rich
March 24, 2022
When do you add the mushrooms back in the pot?
Heidi
February 13, 2022
These were good! I've been curious to try making a miso dessert for a little while now, but wanted it to be grain free. I've found that almond flour based chocolate chip cookies always have some kind of nut butter, and since I just use peanut butter, it's like a PB cookie. The miso did a great job replacing nut butter and achieved a great, chewy consistency! It's definitely strong, although I'm sure white miso would have been more mild. I used dashi miso, which in hindsight sounds pretty gross.. the cookies were not at all fishy tasting, but just bold and kind of salty/savory. I think next time I'll try a little less miso. I have a tendency to use less sugar than a recipe calls for, but I definitely needed it in this one to balance the miso flavor. I just used regular butter too, not ghee.
Susan Renee Hennings
January 12, 2022
Yes, I like it a lot. Lentils are nutritious and inexpensive.
Carole
January 2, 2022
I’m just learning about adaptogens and trying to incorporate them into my “healthy arsenal”. Thanks for the info!
MAdeleine
December 27, 2021
This is the first cinnamon roll recipe i've actually gotten to work! I let the dough rest in the fridge for 4-5 hours and then rolled and filled it, then let it rest in the fridge over night and it worked great for an early morning bake. I looked through the whole recipe and you never mention what temperature to bake at. It just says "place in your preheated oven to bake" I baked at 350. Also it would be really nice if the caramel sauce recipe was included here. All in all totally delicious, worth the effort, and I will be making this again.